102-10 66th, Ste 1D,Forest Hills Queens,NY 11375 Call Us : (718) 275-9792

Silver amalgam fillings last a median 16 years on back teeth and white composite about 11, while composite matches the tooth and bonds to it. That gap is real, and it has narrowed. The bigger variable is who places the filling and on which tooth. I have placed composite in Forest Hills since 1996 and teach other dentists to place it on molars.

Key Highlights

  • Amalgam survives a median of over 16 years on back teeth, composite about 11 years, in a 2025 review of adult studies
  • Composite is resin and glass with no mercury; amalgam is about 50% mercury bound with silver, tin, and copper
  • The FDA names seven higher-risk groups who should avoid amalgam where possible, and says the evidence does not show harm for most other people
  • The FDA and the ADA both say intact silver fillings in good condition should stay in
  • Many insurance plans pay for a composite on a molar at the amalgam rate, and the patient pays the difference
White (composite)Silver (amalgam)
What it's made ofResin plus glass filler, no mercuryAbout 50% mercury with silver, tin, and copper
How long it lasts on back teethAbout 11 years medianOver 16 years median
How it stays inBonds to the toothHeld by the shape of the cavity
How much tooth comes outThe decay, and little elseThe decay plus healthy tooth cut for grip
Where it's usedFront and back teethBack teeth
What it costs, national average$173 to $439 per tooth$108 to $256 per tooth

Lifespan figures are medians from a 2025 systematic review of adult back-tooth restorations. Cost figures are national fee-survey averages, not Forest Hills Dental’s fees.

Which filling lasts longer, white or silver?

Silver, on the evidence, and the margin is about five years of median survival on back teeth. The 2025 review above put amalgam past 16 years and composite near 11.

The reason the two fail is different, and that matters more than the number. Composite most often fails when decay creeps in at the edge where the filling meets the tooth. Amalgam most often fails when the filling, or the tooth around it, fractures.

Think of the two materials this way. Amalgam is packed into the tooth like gravel into a hole, and it stays because the hole is shaped to grip it. Composite is glued in like a patch on a tire. The gravel hole has to be undercut to hold, which costs healthy tooth. The patch holds on its own, but only if the surface was clean and dry when it went on. A composite placed on a wet tooth is a composite that will leak.

The Cochrane review from 2021 found low-certainty evidence that composite on back teeth may fail at close to double the rate of amalgam, with more decay at the margins. The same authors noted that the trials were old and that composite materials had improved a great deal since they were run. The evidence is not all one way: a 2025 meta-analysis in the International Dental Journal found no statistically significant difference in failure risk between the two. Taken together, amalgam has the longer record and the gap is smaller than the older trials suggest. Both reviews name the same two patient factors as the ones that move the result most: how clean the teeth are kept, and whether the person grinds.

If you grind, a night guard for teeth grinding protects either material, and I would rather fit one than replace a cracked filling every few years.

Do white fillings last as long as silver fillings?

Not quite, on average. Across adult studies amalgam lasts a median of over 16 years on back teeth and composite about 11. The gap closes when the composite is small, kept dry during placement, and bonded to enamel. A large composite on a molar in a grinder is the case that drags the average down.

Is the mercury in silver fillings a problem?

For most people, the FDA says no. For seven named groups, it says avoid amalgam where possible and appropriate.

Dental amalgam is about half mercury by weight, bound with silver, tin, and copper into a stable metal. It releases a small amount of mercury vapor over time, more during placement and removal. The FDA’s position, updated in September 2020, is that the majority of evidence suggests this exposure does not lead to harmful health effects for most people.

The FDA recommends that these groups avoid amalgam when another material will do:

  • Pregnant women and their developing fetuses
  • Women who are planning to become pregnant
  • Nursing women and their newborns and infants
  • Children, especially those younger than six
  • People with pre-existing neurological disease
  • People with impaired kidney function
  • People with known heightened sensitivity (allergy) to mercury or other components of dental amalgam

The American Dental Association responded the same week that amalgam is durable, safe, and effective and is not harmful to the general population. Composite contains no mercury. That is a fact about the material, and I state it as one. It is a reason some patients prefer composite, and for the groups above it is a reason the FDA agrees with. It is not evidence that a silver filling already in your mouth is hurting you.

For context on where the material is heading: the European Union stopped the use of dental amalgam on 1 January 2025, and the Minamata Convention set a global end to its manufacture and trade for 2035. The United States has not banned it.

Are silver fillings safe for children?

The FDA lists children, especially those under six, among the groups who should avoid amalgam where possible, citing uncertainty about long-term exposure rather than proven harm. Composite is what we place on children’s teeth for that reason. An existing amalgam in a child’s baby tooth that is intact does not need to come out.

We Can't Wait to Meet You!

Call Us Today to Schedule Your Consultation!

Should I replace my silver fillings with white ones?

Not while they are intact. Replace a silver filling when it fails, not because it is silver.

The question comes up most often with new patients in their forties and fifties, and the answer surprises people. The FDA and the ADA both advise against removing amalgam fillings in good condition unless there is a medical reason. Drilling out a sound amalgam releases more mercury vapor than leaving it in place, by the FDA’s own account, and every replacement takes a little more healthy tooth with it. A tooth that has been filled three times is a tooth heading toward a crown.

A silver filling has failed, and should be replaced, when I see one of these:

  • A visible crack in the filling or a gap at the edge
  • Decay under or beside it on the X-ray
  • A dark line along the margin that was not there at the last visit
  • A cracked cusp or a tooth that hurts when you bite and release
  • New sensitivity to cold on a tooth that was quiet for years

A patient came in last year asking me to swap all eight of her silver fillings for white ones before a wedding. The X-rays showed two with decay underneath. We replaced those two in composite. The other six were sound, so they stayed, and we photographed them so we can compare at each checkup. She got the two front-visible teeth she cared about fixed and kept six teeth from losing more structure for no clinical reason.

When a filling does fail, how it failed decides the fix. A small crack gets a new filling. A cracked cusp is a different conversation, and the post on what to do when a tooth cracks around an old filling walks through it.

Can I replace silver fillings with white?

Yes, when the silver filling has failed or the tooth around it has. A dentist removes the amalgam and any decay, isolates the tooth to keep it dry, and bonds composite in its place in one visit. If the cavity is large after the old filling is out, an onlay or crown holds up better than a second large filling.

Which filling is right for which tooth?

Front teeth get composite without debate. Back teeth are where the decision lives, and the size of the cavity matters more than the colour of the material.

On a front tooth, composite is the only material that disappears, and the chewing load is low enough that durability is not the deciding factor. On molars and premolars, the question is how much tooth is left once the decay is out.

A small to medium cavity on a molar does well in composite when the tooth is kept dry during placement and the bond is to sound enamel. This is the case where the longevity gap is smallest. A large cavity that undermines a cusp is not a filling question at all. Packing a big composite into a thin shell of tooth puts a lot of load on a small bond, and a big amalgam in the same tooth acts like a wedge when you bite. Either one tends to crack the cusp. That tooth wants a CEREC inlay or onlay, which covers and protects the remaining tooth instead of sitting inside it.

Choosing a filling by colour alone is like choosing a roof by colour. Fine for the part people see. The back of the house gets the material that handles the load, and on a back tooth that means the material and the size that match the forces, with colour second.

Small chips and worn edges on front teeth are a related but separate decision, covered in the post on composite bonding on front teeth.

If you have been told you need a filling and want to know which material fits that tooth, that is a 15-minute conversation with your X-ray in front of us.

See what a white filling involves.

We go over the material, the size of the cavity, and what your plan pays, and nothing is scheduled until you have those answers.

Why does Forest Hills Dental place white fillings?

Because I can keep more of the tooth, bond the restoration to what is left, and match the colour, and because the longevity gap closes when the placement is done properly.

Amalgam is a good material with a long record, and I am not going to pretend otherwise in an article that has just told you it lasts longer on average. The case for composite in my practice rests on four things. It needs no extra tooth cut away for grip, so a small cavity stays a small filling. It bonds to the tooth, which lets me rebuild a corner or a cusp that amalgam could only sit beside. It matches, which patients care about on premolars that show when they laugh. And the FDA’s higher-risk list covers most of the children and pregnant patients a family practice sees in a week, so composite is the default those patients would be steered to anyway.

The longevity gap is the price of those four things, and it is a price I can shrink. I teach a hands-on course for dentists on posterior composite and partial restorations, and the whole course is about the details that decide whether a white filling on a molar lasts 6 years or 15: isolation, bonding to enamel, building the filling in layers, and shaping the bite so one spot does not take every hit.

Why does insurance only cover silver fillings on back teeth?

Many plans pay for the least expensive material that works, which on a molar is amalgam, and bill you the difference if you choose composite.

The practice is called an alternate benefit, or a downgrade. Insurers say it plainly on their own employer pages: many plans cover silver fillings on back teeth but not white ones. Front teeth are usually covered in composite at the full rate. It is a cost rule, not a clinical opinion about which material is better for your tooth.

Here is how the math usually runs. Your plan allows $200 for an amalgam on that tooth and the composite fee is $320. The plan pays 80% of its $200 allowance, which is $160. You pay the remaining $160, instead of the $64 you would owe on a covered composite. Numbers are an example; your plan’s allowance will differ.

Before treatment, ask the front desk one question: “Does my plan downgrade composite on molars?” Our team checks this before the appointment, and financing options are there for the difference if you want composite on a tooth your plan would rather fill in silver.

Are white fillings more expensive?

Yes, before insurance. National fee-survey averages put a composite filling at $173 to $439 per tooth and an amalgam at $108 to $256, depending on the tooth and how many surfaces are filled. Those are aggregator estimates, not our fees. Forest Hills Dental quotes your filling after an exam and X-ray, once we know the size.

We Can't Wait to Meet You!

Call Us Today to Schedule Your Consultation!

White vs silver fillings: TL;DR

  • Silver amalgam lasts longer on back teeth: a median of over 16 years against about 11 for composite
  • Composite bonds to the tooth, needs less drilling, and matches the colour
  • The FDA says amalgam is not shown to harm most people and names seven higher-risk groups who should avoid it where possible
  • Intact silver fillings stay in; they come out when they crack, leak, or show decay
  • Many plans pay for a composite on a molar at the silver rate, so ask the front desk first

If you have an old silver filling you are unsure about, the right first step is an X-ray and a look at the margins, not a decision about colour.

Book a filling check in Forest Hills.

Call or text (718) 275-9792, Monday to Friday, 10 am to 7 pm.

Common questions about white and silver fillings

Are white fillings better than silver fillings?

Neither is better in every case. Composite wins on appearance, on bonding, and on how much tooth is kept. Amalgam wins on average lifespan on back teeth and on price. A small cavity, a front tooth, a child, or a pregnant patient points to composite. A large molar cavity in a heavy grinder is where amalgam’s record counts most.

Do white fillings stain?

Over years, yes. Coffee, tea, red wine, and smoking darken the surface of composite, and the edge can pick up a line. A polish at a cleaning removes most surface stain. Amalgam does not stain, but it can turn the surrounding tooth grey from the inside, which no polish fixes.

How much do white fillings cost compared with silver?

National fee-survey averages run $173 to $439 per tooth for composite and $108 to $256 for amalgam, with the exact figure set by the tooth and the number of surfaces. Those are estimates, not Forest Hills Dental’s fees. We quote after an exam and X-ray, and CareCredit financing is available for any difference your plan does not cover.

Does a white filling hurt more than a silver one?

No. Both are placed under the same local anaesthetic. Composite can leave a tooth sensitive to cold for a few days or weeks while the bond settles, and the Cochrane review found no consistent difference in sensitivity between the two materials after placement. Sensitivity that gets worse rather than better needs a look.

How do I know if my old silver filling needs replacing?

Five signs: a visible crack or gap at the edge, decay beside or under it on an X-ray, a new dark line along the margin, pain when you bite and release, or new cold sensitivity on a tooth that was quiet. None of them is colour. A silver filling with none of these stays in.

Testimonials

See what our patients have to say about us!